FROM COLONIAL ORDINANCE TO CHILD RIGHTS ACT: A CRITICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE EVOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION GAPS IN NIGERIA'S JUVENILE JUSTICE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
), Ejiro Tessy Kore-Okiti(2), Kingsley Tito Esiso(3),
(1) 
(2) 
(3) 
Corresponding Author
Abstract
This Article critically re-examines the administration of juvenile justice in Nigeria, tracing its evolution from the colonial-era Children and Young Persons Ordinance 1943 to the contemporary Child Rights Act (CRA) 2003. Drawing on the legal transplantation theory, it argues that Nigeria’s juvenile justice system is a clear example of “fragmented legal transplantation”, and that this fragmentation undermines the effective realisation of children’s rights guaranteed under international treaties. The central contention is that the CRA’s domestication requirement is not merely administrative but a constitutional mechanism that sustains colonial-era fragmentation, rendering the Act a symbolic commitment that denies millions of Nigerian children the protections that international law and national legislation purport to guarantee. The paper employs the comparative method to draw lessons from India and South Africa. India, like Nigeria, has successfully enacted unified laws on juvenile justice. Both jurisdictions provide instructive contrasts to Nigeria’s fragmented approach, while recognising their peculiar historical and political contexts. This Article identifies three structural impediments to uniform child rights protection. It examines how statutes and customary and religious (Sharia/customary court) orders create jurisdictional clashes that undermine unified child rights protections. This Article concludes by proposing a dual reform: first, a constitutional amendment to include juvenile justice on the Exclusive Legislative List; and second, a federal fiscal initiative adopting conditional access to certain federal allocations based on state adoption and enforcement of the CRA, with non-compliant states losing eligibility.
Keywords
Article Metrics
Abstract View
: 9 times
Download : 3 times
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.

